Has Europe Dropped the Ball on Biodiversity?
ARTE.tv DocumentarySome experts believe the world is living through a new age of extinction, possibly the largest since the era of the dinosaurs, and this time, the programme says, "it's humans that are the asteroid." In this episode of ARTE Europe Weekly, timed to the COP17 biodiversity summit, the presenter asks whether Europe, which led the push for a global nature deal four years ago, has since let that ambition slip. The episode argues that it largely has. It points to weakened pesticide rules and a watered-down restoration law. It also points to examples showing that recovery is possible, and argues that protecting biodiversity makes economic sense.
COP17: A Disappointing Annual Review
The presenter compares this week's summit in Yerevan, Armenia, to an annual review with your boss when you know you haven't done much. COP17 was the first global review of progress since almost every country signed the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework in 2022. The programme's verdict is blunt: the world is "way off track."
The programme calls the 2022 deal "extraordinarily ambitious." Among other goals, countries committed to two targets by 2030:
- restoring 30% of the world's most degraded ecosystems
- conserving 30% of the planet's land and sea ecosystems
According to UN estimates cited in the episode, if the current pace continues, about 26% of the world's land ecosystems will be conserved by 2030. Only 12% of marine ecosystems will be.
Europe's Moment of Glory in Montreal
The programme recalls the close of COP15 in 2022, when European leaders were "basking in glory." It describes the EU as the driving force behind the negotiations. Coming off the European Green Deal, the EU helped set ambitious global restoration targets, described as "a sort of Paris agreement for biodiversity." In archive footage, an official remarks that ministers from some countries had said agreement on certain points was impossible, yet those points had been agreed that day.
"It was a different era," the narrator says. Since then, according to the programme, the green wave has subsided and the EU has scaled back its ambitions.
Pesticides: The Clearest Step Backwards
The episode presents plant protection products as the main symbol of this retreat. It says these products are largely responsible for the collapse of insect populations in Europe. As a result, it says, certain insect-eating birds have all but disappeared from the countryside.
The programme lists several setbacks. In late 2023, some European countries voted against a ban on glyphosate. Because there was no qualified majority, authorisation for the controversial herbicide was extended to 2033. In 2024, farmers protested a proposed regulation to halve pesticide use in the EU by 2030. The Commission eventually gave in and shelved the proposal. The programme attributes this partly to lobbying pressure.
A Restoration Law, but a Diluted One
Despite that pressure, the EU did adopt a major biodiversity law in August 2024. It requires member states to restore nature across land, waterways and seas. The programme stresses that this law, too, was weakened from its original draft. A proposal to make 10% of cultivated land more ecologically diverse was removed. Countries were originally going to have to prove tangible results. Now, the programme says, the Commission merely wants to see that they have put measures in place.
The "Simplification" Drive and the Pesticides Omnibus
The narrator argues that environmental protection has slipped down the EU's priorities. Instead, Brussels is on a "simplification drive" focused on cutting red tape, increasing margins and making EU farmers more competitive.
One part of this drive is a highly controversial bill called the Pesticides Omnibus. Under current rules, the active substances in pesticides are approved for a maximum of 15 years before they must be reviewed. The programme says the new law would essentially approve them indefinitely. More than 500 scientists and doctors from across Europe have signed an open letter asking the EU to drop the proposal. They warn that pesticides are linked to health problems in humans, on top of their environmental impact.
The Scale of Biodiversity Loss in Europe
The programme names agricultural runoff and farm-driven habitat destruction as some of the factors behind biodiversity loss. It cites 2023 research that examined more than 14,000 animal and plant species on a European list of endangered species. The researchers found that one in five are threatened with extinction:
- Plants: 27% at risk, including native species such as the rowan tree.
- Invertebrates: 24% threatened, including the freshwater pearl mussel and the wild bee.
- Vertebrates: 18% threatened, such as the European mink.
Dunsany Castle: A Rewilding Success Story
The episode then turns to places where the trend is being reversed. Dunsany Castle, a 12th-century castle 35 km northwest of Dublin, now hosts Ireland's largest private rewilding project. It sits within a 650-hectare estate that has belonged to the Plunkett family for six centuries.
The estate's owner explains that the castle has stood since 1180. The Normans settled there because the land was so good for farming. When the rewilding began, the owner says, people dismissed them as "a bourgeois idiot from a castle who's going to destroy good farmland." According to the owner, those critics "didn't understand that without nature we won't have farming."
About half the estate has been dedicated to rewilding, and scientists from Trinity College Dublin are documenting its progress. The owner describes planting trees and hedgerows. At first, local farmers thought the owner was crazy. Then older residents began to see animals they had not seen since childhood. The programme says native species have returned and the grass has not been cut since 2014.
The narrator links projects like this to climate change. Natural ecosystems act as carbon sinks, so restoring them helps mitigate global warming. It also protects food systems and the economy.
Why Biodiversity Matters: Food, Water, Air and the Economy
The programme then lays out the case for biodiversity. Everything we eat comes from plants and animals. The greater the variety of species, the more resilient the food chain. If a system relies on a single crop, such as one grain variety, a single pest could wipe out an entire harvest. Biodiversity is presented as the safeguard against that risk.
Beyond food security, the narrator says, biodiversity provides clean water and air. Plants produce oxygen through photosynthesis. Forests and peatlands act as natural filters that store large amounts of CO2 and purify water and air. "Without biodiversity, the ecosystems we depend on simply cannot function," the narrator says.
The programme also calls nature "the backbone of our economy." It names agriculture, fisheries, forestry and tourism as sectors that depend on it. It states that more than half of the world's economic output relies directly or indirectly on the natural world.
The Money Question
"As ever, it comes down to the money," the narrator says. Some EU member states argue they cannot afford costly conservation projects and that farmers and regions will end up footing the bill. The programme counters with a figure from the European Commission: 6.5 billion euros have been earmarked for nature restoration, and only 15% has been spent so far.
The programme also spoke with the director of WWF France. According to the programme, she argued that investing in nature restoration now is vital to ensure European agriculture survives in the future.
Conclusion
The episode closes by saying that studies show investing in nature now brings long-term financial benefits, and that protecting biodiversity makes societies more resilient. For that reason, the presenter argues, biodiversity should be high on the political agenda in the elections taking place across Europe next year.
Some experts say we're living through another age of extinction. Maybe the biggest one since the dinosaur era. But this time, it's humans that are the asteroid. Four years ago, Europe led the charge in protecting the planet's ecosystems. But since then, progress has stalled. Has Europe dropped the ball on biodiversity?
You know that feeling when you have your annual review with your boss and you know you haven't really done much. That must be how global leaders felt in Yerevan, Armenia, this week at the COP17 summit on biodiversity. It was the first global review of the progress made since almost every country in the world signed up to the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework in 2022.
And to put it frankly, the world is way off track. It was an extraordinarily ambitious deal. Among other goals, countries committed to restoring 30% of the world's most degraded ecosystems and conserving 30% of the planet's land and sea ecosystems. And all of this by 2030. If we keep going at the current rate, the UN estimates that by 2030, we'll have conserved 26% of the world's land ecosystems, but only 12% of marine ones.
At the time, Europe played a major role in fighting to get the deal over the line. But what has its track record been like since?
Montreal, 2022. The COP15 on biodiversity is drawing to a spectacular close with European leaders basking in glory. The EU was the driving force behind the negotiations. After the European Green Deal, they helped to set ambitious global targets for restoring nature across the world, a sort of Paris Agreement for biodiversity.
Yesterday I had a meeting with ministers from some countries and they said that it's impossible to agree. I see that a number of points that they said it's impossible to have been today is agreed.
It was a different era. Since then this green wave has subsided and the EU has scaled back its ambitions. One symbol of this step backwards relates to plant protection products and their disastrous impact on biodiversity. These products are largely responsible for the collapse of insect populations in Europe. As a result of this, certain insect-eating birds have all but disappeared from our countrysides.
Despite this, in late 2023, some European countries voted against a ban on glyphosate. Without a qualified majority, authorization for the controversial herbicide was extended to 2033. In 2024, farmers rallied against a proposed regulation to halve pesticide use in the EU by 2030. The Commission eventually gave in and the proposal was shelved.
Sant
Lobbying
Facility, the same lobby.
Despite pressure from lobbies, the EU did manage to adopt a major biodiversity law in August 2024. The legislation requires member states to restore natural biodiversity across land, waterways, and seas. But here too, the original draft has been watered down. The idea of making 10% of cultivated land more ecologically diverse, for example, has been taken out. And whereas before countries would have had to prove tangible results, now the Commission merely wants to see that they have put measures in place.
With everything else going on, it seems that protecting the environment has slipped down the EU's list of priorities. Instead, Brussels is on a simplification drive, cutting red tape, increasing margins, and making EU farmers more competitive. And one part of that is a highly controversial bill called the Pesticides Omnibus. At the moment, the active substances in pesticides only get approved for maximum 15 years before they have to be reviewed. This law would essentially greenlight them indefinitely.
More than 500 scientists and doctors from across Europe have signed an open letter calling on the EU to drop the proposed new rules, warning that pesticides are linked to health problems in humans, not to mention their impact on the environment. Pollution from agricultural runoff and the destruction of habitats due to farming are just some of the factors leading to biodiversity loss.
In 2023, researchers looked at more than 14,000 species of animals and plants on a list of endangered species in Europe and found that one in five are threatened with extinction. 27% of plants are at risk of extinction. Even native species such as the rowan tree are affected. Next on the hit list are invertebrates with 24% threatened, including species such as the freshwater pearl mussel and the wild bee. Vertebrates are not safe either. 18% of them are threatened with extinction, such as the European mink.
There are places in Europe where this trend is being reversed. A 12th-century castle just 35 km northwest of Dublin is now home to Ireland's largest private rewilding project. Dunsany Castle sits within a 650-hectare estate. It's been in the Plunkett family for six centuries.
The castle has been here since 1180 and the Normans stopped here because the land was so good and they wanted to farm here. But it's interesting, for rewilding people said, a bourgeois idiot from a castle who's going to destroy good farmland. They didn't understand that without nature we won't have farming.
About half of the land has been dedicated to rewilding. Scientists from Trinity College Dublin are documenting its progress.
We started planting trees. We started planting hedgerows. And at first the farmers just thought I was crazy, but then the old people who live in this area began to see animals they haven't seen since they were children.
The project has allowed the landscape to regenerate after centuries of farming. Native species have returned, and the grass hasn't been cut since 2014.
Restoration projects like this also do their part to tackle the wider issue of climate change. Natural ecosystems act as carbon sinks. So, if we restore them, it not only helps us mitigate the impact of global warming, but protects our food systems and our economy.
Let's look at the matter of basic sustenance. Everything we eat comes from plants and animals. The greater the variety of plant and animal species there are, the more resilient and secure our food chain. Reliance on a single crop, such as one grain variety, means that a single pest could wipe out an entire harvest. Biodiversity is our safeguard against that risk.
But beyond food security, it also gives us clean water and air. Through photosynthesis, plants produce vital oxygen. Forests and peatlands act as natural filters that store massive amounts of CO2 and purify our water and air. Without biodiversity, the ecosystems we depend on simply cannot function.
Nature is also the backbone of our economy. Agriculture, fisheries, forestry, and tourism are just a few sectors that depend on biodiversity. In fact, more than half of the world's economic output relies directly or indirectly on the natural world.
As ever, it comes down to the money. Some EU member states say that they can't afford costly conservation projects and that farmers and regions will end up footing the bill. But according to the EU Commission, 6.5 billion euros have been earmarked for nature restoration projects and only 15% of that has been spent so far.
We spoke to the director of the France chapter of the World Wildlife Fund. She told us that it's vital to put money into nature restoration now to ensure the survival of Europe's agricultural sector in the future.
Restoration.
Foreconomic
Studies have shown that if we invest in nature now, that will have a long-term financial benefit. Protecting biodiversity has the effect of making our societies more resilient. So, it should be high on the political agenda in elections all across Europe next year. On that, we'll see you next week and goodbye.
Article published · Updated
