Ryuji Tries Ichikakuya, Called "the Worst Ramen Chain," to See for Himself

Translated from 日本語

Open on YouTube ↗
Overview

Cooking researcher Ryuji visited Ichikakuya for the first installment of a series in which he eats his way through ramen chains. The chain gets a lot of comments online calling it "the least tasty of all the chains," but neither Ryuji nor the staff member with him had ever eaten there. The goal this time was to find out whether it's really that bad.

6 min read
0:19

Getting In and Ordering

The location they arrived at was a combined Ichikakuya and Abura Soba Sohonten. Even at lunchtime, there was only one customer. Ryuji went in half-doubtful, saying, "Is there really such a thing as a ramen shop that's not that good?"

At the ticket machine, the "MAX Ramen," which comes with toppings, appeared to be the most popular item. The staff member chose the standard iekei (soy sauce), and Ryuji chose salt. Garlic, doubanjiang, fish powder, and other condiments were lined up on the table, all free to use. Ryuji said he likes that at places like this you can add as much as you want without holding back. According to a notice posted in the shop, chopped onions can also be requested for free. They also mentioned that a tweet saying "I came to Ichikakuya to punish myself" had reportedly gone viral online.

The ramen that arrived had thick noodles, chashu that looked closer to ham, and relatively little oil on the surface.

3:10

How It Actually Tasted: Salt Over Soy Sauce

After tasting the broth, both agreed it was pork-bone based and on the salty side, but without any off-putting smell. The spinach didn't taste strange either. The broth was hot and the garlic came through, and Ryuji was surprised: "This is totally fine, actually."

Comparing the soy sauce and the salt versions, both decided the salt was better. The salt broth was quite intense and somewhat salty, but its flavor was clearly defined. Ryuji praised it as standing on its own even without adding garlic. The soy sauce wasn't bad either, and they concluded it would come down to personal preference.

As his own way of eating it, Ryuji poured a little broth over rice and topped it with the toppings. That's when he noticed the amount of broth was a bit on the small side. With doubanjiang added, they felt garlic would go well with the soy sauce version, and the chopped onions also went over well for being tasty and not too sharp. Adding fish powder made it taste like a seafood-style ramen. Both also said the rice was firm and good.

5:56

The Only Flaw: The Amount of Broth

Even as they kept eating, the two couldn't find the reason it's called "bad." They praised the shop's attention to detail, such as warmed bowls that keep the broth from cooling quickly. The only flaw they could point to, if pressed, was that there wasn't much broth.

Ryuji speculated that it might just be iekei ramen otaku refusing to accept chain shops and nitpicking. The staff member said the taste differed from Machida Shoten, which they eat at occasionally, and that Machida Shoten's is sharper. On the other hand, they also suggested that since Machida Shoten is salty too, the salt levels might be similar. Because it's fairly salty, Ryuji said it's the kind of flavor he'd want to eat after drinking.

7:50

Why the Bad Reputation, and Why Sales Are Falling

Ryuji raised the question: "If it weren't tasty, wouldn't it be impossible to expand as a chain in the first place?" Ichikakuya apparently has around 140 locations. The staff member said that, ironically, there were so many locations that they had never gone into one.

Their verdict was that while there might be a gap compared with independent ramen shops, as a chain there's nothing wrong with it at all. Regarding the reports that sales are falling, Ryuji speculated that the ramen boom may have brought in more strong competitors, making things tough. The staff member brought up the price of rice, speculating that while it used to be free at some locations, they may have stopped offering it for free when rice prices soared, and that customers may have decided to go elsewhere instead. These were all their own guesses, not presented as confirmed information.

On the other hand, they cited the wide range of paid toppings, such as fried onions, as a plus. As for the richness of the salt broth, Ryuji thinks it comes from animal fat rather than butter.

10:24

Comparisons With Other Chains, and Ryuji's Approach

The two compared it with the Denny's ramen supervised by Iida Shoten that they had eaten before. That one was truly awful, and the staff member said they felt "I can't do this." By comparison, Ryuji said Ichikakuya "properly works as ramen." He did add the caveat, however, that people who prefer lighter ramen would probably find it heavy.

They also mentioned that the broth is apparently made in a central kitchen, which may mean it's more consistent. Ryuji said he doesn't pay attention to prior information, such as whether a shop makes its own broth, and judges only by the bowl in front of him. He said that if it were served to him without any prior information, he might think it was ramen from an ordinary ramen shop. Ryuji's assessment was that the seasoning is crowd-pleasing, with its distinctive features deliberately toned down, but that it's still tasty.

11:19

Conclusion

In the end, Ryuji summed it up with "At Ichikakuya, it's the salt," and said his expectations had been defied in a good way. The two agreed that the salt version is quite salty. Their conclusion was that although it gets bashed online, it was tasty when they actually ate it. Both of them finished their bowls.