Florida's Anti-Vaccine Turn: Inside the MAHA Movement and the Scientists Who Say They Are Losing

Open on YouTube ↗
Overview

This ARTE documentary uses Florida as a case study for how anti-vaccine beliefs have moved from the fringe into government in the United States. It follows the people who welcome that shift: a Miami mother who distrusts vaccines, an award-winning state surgeon general, self-described "vaccine injured" activists, and two podcasting "MAHA moms." It sets them against doctors, teachers and a former top CDC official who warn of serious consequences. The film's framing is that Florida is a "political laboratory" for the country, and that the Trump administration's health secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., has given anti-vaccine positions their strongest platform yet.

15 min read
0:07

Florida's Announcement and a Mother's Relief

The film opens on 3 September 2025, when Florida's Surgeon General, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, announced that the state's Department of Health, in partnership with the governor, would work to end "all vaccine mandates in Florida. All of them." In the speech he tells listeners that authorities "don't have the right to tell you what your kids have to put in your body," and urges them not to give that right away. In practical terms, this means lifting school vaccination requirements.

In Miami, Paula Nevatala watches the speech from home. For Paula, a fairly affluent Hispanic parent of two whom the narration describes as not particularly politicized, the news was a relief, "especially for kids." Paula insists on not being "an anti-vaxxer person," and says everyone should "do their own homework and get informed." Paula's children are vaccinated, but have received "just some vaccines."

According to the film, Paula lost faith in vaccines after the COVID-19 pandemic and now relies on Ayurvedic medicine. Showing a supplement cabinet, Paula describes Ayurveda as the best-known and most ancient medicine. Paula's approach follows the idea of letting food be medicine: rather than taking paracetamol, Paula takes an "anti-inflammatory route," which Paula says sometimes works faster than a painkiller. Asked whether this inspires more trust than vaccines, Paula answers: "I trust more my body reactions," and argues that the way one lives gives the body more tools to fight infection. The narration presents Paula as an example of "wellness culture versus scientific truth," and of the growing reach of anti-vaccine beliefs.

2:55

Kennedy's Department and the Federal Backdrop

The documentary attributes that growth partly to promotion from the top of the federal government. It says Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has "cleaned out" his department, ended numerous vaccine research programs, and restricted access to vaccines that he deems disease-causing, contrary to scientific consensus. The film includes a clip of an official statement that, after reviewing the science and consulting experts at the NIH and FDA, HHS "has determined that mRNA technology poses more risk than benefits for these respiratory viruses."

The narration argues that this federal "anti-vaccine fever" has emboldened Kennedy's allies in Republican-led states, Ladapo foremost among them.

3:42

Ladapo as a MAHA Hero

The film follows Ladapo to an event held by an anti-vaccine organization, where he receives a "courageous health freedom award" for lifting school vaccination requirements. The narration describes a "rockstar reception" for the Harvard-trained physician, who has run health policy in Florida since 2021.

In his speech, Ladapo calls the conflict "a spiritual war." He says that, however "bland and normal" CNN newscasters and others try to make masking, shutdowns or vaccine requirements seem, those measures are, in his words, "messages for our enslavement as human beings." The narration notes that statements like these have put him at odds with the scientific community. It argues, though, that this outcast status has made him a hero and "whistleblower" for MAHA (Make America Healthy Again), the movement led by Kennedy.

Attendees praise him as "phenomenal" and say he wants to bring freedom to people who want control over their own life, health and body. One attendee says their 38-year-old daughter has never had a vaccine, and that the family has been "aware of the dangers of vaccines for decades."

The film cites polling figures to put this in context. According to the narration, since the pandemic 60% of Republicans oppose mandatory vaccination, and barely one in four think it important to vaccinate their children. Many go further and believe vaccines have made them ill. One woman at the event says she received two Moderna COVID vaccines and suffered enlarged lymph nodes, which her primary doctor asked her to report to VAERS. She now has multiple myeloma and says she will "never ever ever touch another vaccine again."

The narration counters that a major 2021 study by the US federal health agency found that mRNA vaccines do not increase the risk of death, a finding it says France's national health insurance system confirmed this year. Even so, it says the "vax injured" are becoming more visible and are forming a movement of their own.

7:44

Dan: Podcaster, Former Pharma Rep, and Laser Clinic Operator

One of that movement's voices is Dan, an Orlando podcaster whom the film says reaches tens of thousands of subscribers daily. On his show he claims that in recent weeks there have been "two different incidents of confirmation" that injuries are caused by vaccinations. He calls this a global problem, with Florida at "the tip of the spear" against "poison pushing big pharma," and he calls for a return to "God-given, natural, innate immune systems." He says he has interviewed the injured for more than five years, and that the work is personal because he has lost friends and knows others who are still suffering.

The film notes that the vaccine-injured, once on the margins, have had a powerful ally in the White House for the past year. Kennedy is working on legislation to compensate Americans who believe a vaccine made them ill. Dan says Kennedy has been "fighting for the injured" for more than 20 years, and that he was ecstatic when MAHA came to power.

Dan, a former pharmaceutical sales representative, has also started a business treating people who believe the mRNA vaccine poisoned them. The film shows him picking up a patient, Deshay, an Orlando retiree who he says cannot drive because of chronic illness and inflammation. Deshay believes she was harmed by the vaccine even though she has never been vaccinated. She thinks she was passively exposed through a vaccinated neighbor, by way of breath, aerosols, sweat and "bodily fluids type of thing."

At his clinic, Dan uses what he calls cold laser therapy, presented as a way to clear the vaccine's adverse effects. He says the therapy was originally approved in the US about a decade ago for three things: decreasing inflammation, increasing circulation and decreasing pain. He argues these are exactly what almost every vaccine-injury patient is dealing with. Because Deshay has not visited for a while, he adds light "glasses" to her session. He then moves on to "treating the brain," targeting the occipital and frontal areas. He says this helped him recover from strokes and from diagnoses of early Alzheimer's and CTE, and he quotes Genesis: "And let there be light."

The narration stresses that Dan is neither a doctor nor a nurse. He treats a small number of patients a day and charges between $200 and $400 per session.

13:25

The Attack on the CDC

The documentary then turns to what it presents as the most extreme expression of this distrust. It says some people now see the CDC as an enemy to be taken down "quite literally." On 8 August 2025, a 30-year-old man armed with an assault rifle attacked the CDC's headquarters in Atlanta. The narration describes him as vaccine injured and convinced that the COVID vaccine had poisoned him. More than 500 bullets struck the building. One police officer was killed, and thousands of health workers were left deeply traumatized.

Among them was Dr. Demetre Daskalakis, whose office was hit by several bullets. He was not there that day because he was having surgery, but he says he spent it calling staff who were hiding in conference rooms after being "shot at for 20 minutes." He says Kennedy visited, offered "thoughts and prayers," and then left for a news segment where he told people not to trust experts. Daskalakis holds Kennedy "responsible for the environment that allowed for that shooting to happen."

14:47

A Senior Scientist Resigns

The film introduces Daskalakis as one of the most renowned epidemiologists in the United States, who led the CDC's vaccination policy until last August. When Kennedy's reforms went against his scientific data, he resigned. At the end of August, former colleagues formed a guard of honor and applauded him out of the building.

A few hours earlier he had posted his resignation letter publicly. In it he wrote that he could not serve in an environment that treats the CDC "as a tool to generate policies and materials that do not reflect scientific reality and are designed to hurt rather than to improve the public's health."

In the interview, he describes "a vast literature of conspiracy" and says one reason for his resignation was that people who hold those conspiracy beliefs are now in charge of national vaccine recommendations. He rejects specific claims directly. He says the narrative that mRNA vaccines are contaminated with DNA and alter your genes is untrue, and that there has been no surge in cancer linked to mRNA vaccines. This, he says, is what happens when a health secretary "elevates conspiracy theorists to the place of prominence."

16:42

Predicting a "Dark Ages of Public Health"

Daskalakis believes the worst is still ahead. He says the US had a "golden age" of public health in which HIV and vaccine-preventable diseases were brought under control, and in which tuberculosis is seen mainly through cases brought in from other countries. In his view the foundations of that golden age have cracked, and as long as "this very specific health regime" is in power, he expects "pretty bad outcomes."

What worries him most is the delay. The damage will be done now, he says, but much of the outcome will land on the next administration, "whoever that is." For Florida specifically, he predicts that measles vaccination rates will take time to fall because many children are already vaccinated. "Give it a few years, and then you're going to see outbreaks," he says. "I think we're in trouble."

The narration reads his resignation as a verdict that scientists have already lost the battle over the narrative. In the film's account, they have failed to answer daily online attacks from an "army" of small-scale media figures devoted to MAHA.

18:04

The MAHA Moms

The film profiles two of those figures, Aly and Michelle, Florida mothers in their 40s with no medical training who describe themselves as pro-Trump and anti-vaccine. Their podcast opens with "Good morning, Patriot family," and jokes about wearing dark colors for "Dark MAGA" day. They say they started the show to challenge what they see as pro-vaccine propaganda from mainstream media and public health institutions.

One argument they make is about parental guilt and caution. They say many parents feel judged as bad parents at the pediatrician's office for not wanting "a needle put in their child's arm." They also compare doctors' advice to introduce solid foods one at a time to watch for allergic reactions with the practice of giving "five, six different ingredients" in injections to a child under three. "Where's the medicine in that?" they ask.

According to the narration, like many conservative mothers they became politically active during the pandemic by opposing public health restrictions, and then launched the podcast to speak directly to American mothers. They call their audience "MAHA moms" and describe them as "getting back to old school thinking": wanting to know what is injected into their children at birth and what is in their food. They present the network as supportive rather than judgmental, with women educating each other, and they play out a scene of one mother telling another, "you didn't know you had a vaccine exemption in your state, baby girl? Let me send it to you," for free. Moms, they say, are "the biggest marketer," able to make sure the whole neighborhood knows what they think of a business. When moms "activate," they say, "it feels like Avengers assemble."

20:41

Pushback at the Public Meeting

The film then shows that the decision faces strong resistance even in Florida. According to the narration, more than 60% of Floridians oppose lifting school vaccination requirements, and opponents have turned out at public meetings held by the Department of Health. Aly and Michelle drove seven hours to attend one. The narration says healthcare workers, teachers and parents there voiced concern about falling vaccination rates whose consequences are "already clearly visible."

A pediatrician, speaking on behalf of pediatricians, says that in the past six months their hospital has had two patients in the ICU with Hib. One, a four-month-old with no vaccines, died. The other, a two-and-a-half-year-old who had never been vaccinated, arrived a month earlier with brain abscesses and seizures and was declared brain dead. The pediatrician quotes the child's mother: "Please give my child every vaccine we can." The pediatrician argues for keeping the status quo and warns that telling the public vaccines are unimportant or unnecessary "is not the way to do it."

A retired teacher calls themself "a reminder of the past." They grew up before vaccines, when classmates commonly fell sick and died. Once vaccines arrived, they say, "within months, I stopped going to funerals." The teacher warns that the proposal would reopen that door and send the country "back into the dark ages," and pleads with officials to think about future generations.

23:45

Loud Versus Many

Daskalakis argues that the anti-vaccine side is dominant in the conversation but not in numbers. "Their voice is the loudest," he says, but that does not make them the majority. Most Americans, in his view, believe vaccines are important to prevent disease, and only a small minority think no one should ever be vaccinated. The task for science, he concludes, is to make sure "the voice of reason and scientific data starts to overtake the voice of conspiracy."

The documentary closes by describing an already polarized United States with a new dividing line between science and ideology, and between medicine and politics. It presents Florida as a pioneering state in that fight and suggests it may be a preview of America's future.