A "Ground Loop Isolator" From Amazon Turned Out to Be Plain Wire, So the Speaker Built a Real One

Open on YouTube ↗
Overview

The speaker bought an audio "ground loop isolator" on Amazon, intending to test how well this kind of noise filter works. The product turned out to contain nothing but wire. The video explains what a ground loop isolator is supposed to do, shows how the purchased unit failed, and then measures a homemade transformer-based version to see how much ground loop noise it actually removes and where its limits are.

9 min read
1:39

What a Ground Loop Isolator Is Supposed to Be

The speaker first corrects the framing used at the start of the video. Although it was introduced as a noise filter, a ground loop isolator is really a signal isolator. Noise gets onto a signal because of a ground loop. The isolator uses a transformer to electrically separate the signal path, which removes that effect.

In an audio ground loop isolator, the transformer converts the voltage of the audio AC signal. The goal is to keep the signal amplitude the same at input and output, so the turns ratio is often 1:1. Because the transformer sits in the signal path, the ground loop is broken at that point.

2:21

How a Ground Loop Produces Noise

To explain the mechanism, the speaker first draws the circuit without the transformer. Equipment A sends a signal and equipment B receives it, and the two are wired together. Both pieces of equipment are grounded, but for simplicity the speaker treats their grounds as separate, GND-A and GND-B. Suppose a noise source of unknown origin sits between these two grounds. The wiring then forms a loop, and the noise component is transmitted into B.

The speaker adds a qualification: having a ground loop does not guarantee that the loop will cause noise. It only means that it can happen.

3:27

Demonstrating Ground Loop Noise

The speaker set up a simple experiment without a transformer. Equipment A was a signal source and equipment B was a speaker. Their grounds, GND-A and GND-B, were connected by wiring, and a separate noise source was inserted between the two grounds. The connection was only a few tens of centimeters long. The speaker notes that in real setups this wiring could run several meters.

With only the signal applied, a 440 Hz sine wave was heard. When a 2 kHz noise signal was injected into the ground path, the noise became audible along with the tone.

The speaker explains the cause this way. When a voltage is applied across the loop, current flows through it. Real wiring has resistance that does not appear on the schematic, so that current produces a voltage drop. The drop changes the voltage applied to the speaker, and that change is heard as noise. With a ground loop isolator in place, the transformer provides electrical insulation and the loop that carried this current no longer exists.

5:15

The Purchased Isolator Did Nothing

The purchased isolator was then inserted into the same setup. The 440 Hz tone played as before. When the 2 kHz ground noise was added, it should have been inaudible if the device worked. It was still clearly audible.

The product page indicated that the device used a transformer. If so, the input and output terminals should be basically insulated from each other. The speaker measured resistance between terminals and found them connected. The other terminals were connected as well.

When the speaker opened the unit, there was no transformer. Copper wire simply ran from terminal to terminal. The speaker concluded that the device was just a terminal adapter box with no ground loop isolation at all. They called it a complete scam product and said they had been taken in by it.

6:58

Building a Homemade Isolator

The speaker still wanted to know how effective a real ground loop isolator is, so they designed their own circuit. The printed circuit boards were made by JLCPCB, and the capacitors, resistors, and transformers were bought from Akizuki and DigiKey.

Besides the isolation function, the design includes a high-pass filter meant to cut signals below a few tens of hertz. For its capacitors the speaker used Rubycon's PMLCAP, a type of film capacitor. They described it as small with large capacitance, and noted that its capacitance hardly changes even when the applied voltage changes. The speaker said a Rubycon representative told them it is often used in audio applications.

The finished board has the input on the left and the output on the right, with the ground split between the two sides. It carries two channels and uses one transformer per channel. The transformers are Sansui parts bought from Akizuki. The assembly went into an aluminum case. The XLR connectors were taken from the fake product, and the speaker remarked that the result looks quite good.

8:37

Listening Test

Without the isolator, injecting ground loop noise made the noise audible as before. With the homemade isolator, the signal was still heard, although the speaker noted that adding the isolator made the sound slightly different, a little "tinny." When ground loop noise was added, the speaker could no longer hear the noise component by ear.

9:19

Waveforms: Effective at 50 Hz, Leaky at 40 kHz

Next the speaker looked at the output waveform on an oscilloscope. The circuit had been modified so the isolator could be switched in or out for clarity.

Without the isolator, injecting 50 Hz ground loop noise superimposed a 50 Hz component on the original signal waveform. The speaker said this shows the ground loop noise appearing directly in the output. With the isolator, injecting the same 50 Hz noise left the waveform almost unaffected, with no visible change. The speaker called the isolator impressive at this frequency.

The speaker then cautioned that it is not a cure-all. When roughly 40 kHz ground loop noise was injected, high-frequency content appeared on top of the signal waveform even with the isolator. The speaker attributed this to the coupling capacitance between the transformer windings, which lets that component leak through.

10:34

How Much Noise Is Removed Across Frequency

To quantify the rejection, the speaker injected ground loop noise and measured its amplitude on channel 1 and the amplitude at the output on channel 2. Comparing the two channels' frequency responses shows how much of the noise the isolator removes.

At low frequencies the rejection was around −100 dB. The speaker described this as removing the ground loop noise quite well, with a high CMRR. As frequency rose, ground loop noise began to appear at the output starting around the 100 Hz mark. The speaker again attributed this to the interwinding capacitance: as frequency increases, more of the noise component gradually passes to the output side of the transformer.

At 100 kHz the rejection was about −43 dB. The speaker's interpretation is that 1 V of ground loop noise would put roughly 0.01 V onto the output signal. They added that this behavior differs greatly depending on which transformer is used.

11:50

Audio Frequency Response of the Homemade Unit

Since they had built the unit themselves, the speaker also measured how well it passes the audio signal. They said the frequency response came out roughly as expected.

Because of the added high-pass filter, low frequencies are not meant to pass. The measured cutoff was about 120 Hz. The speaker felt this might be a bit high and suggested lowering the cutoff somewhat. Above that the response stays flat for a while. Toward the upper end the phase begins to lag and the gain starts to drop slightly, which the speaker attributed to the transformer's characteristics. The high-side cutoff was 47 kHz, which the speaker thinks will not be a problem for audio use. Gain continues to fall beyond that, to about −6 dB at 100 kHz, which the speaker considered acceptable.

The speaker's assessment is that the homemade isolator is usable for audio signals from about 120 Hz to about 47 kHz. They said the high-pass cutoff only needs small adjustments to suit one's preference.

13:32

Conclusions and What Remains Unknown

To summarize, the speaker bought a fake isolator on Amazon, built their own, and verified its effect. The real isolator reduced ground loop noise enough to make it inaudible. That effectiveness, however, applies to low frequencies up to a few hundred hertz. Above that, some noise leaks through the capacitance between the transformer windings.

The speaker also admitted they have never actually run into noise caused by a ground loop, so they do not know how effective the isolator would be in a real environment. They plan to keep the unit safe in case they need it in the future.