Why Outdated Money Advice Keeps People Stuck: Ramit Sethi on "Boomer" Financial Wisdom

Open on YouTube ↗
Overview

In this reaction video, personal finance author Ramit Sethi watches clips from TikTok, X, BuzzFeed, and YouTube in which younger adults describe money and career advice from their Baby Boomer parents. Sethi opens with the pattern he sees: in this kind of advice, every financial struggle becomes a personal moral failing. If you can't afford a house, you should have worked harder. If you're struggling with money, you're buying too many lattes. Rising housing costs, expensive childcare, and higher education prices drop out of the picture, and the answer is always more discipline. Sethi sets out to test whether any of this advice actually helps people, or whether it mostly makes younger people feel bad.

17 min read

His position, built up over the clips, has two parts. He agrees that the structure of the economy has changed in ways older generations often don't grasp, and he is openly scathing about some of them. He also insists that younger viewers take responsibility for what they can control, especially spending they routinely undercount.

0:48

Stop Seeking Your Parents' Approval on Housing

The first clip comes from Jenni Fink, a 33-year-old millennial who is trying to buy a house. They describe a recurring mistake: talking to their Boomer parents about it. They send listings, such as a three-bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath home, and the parents object that a couple who both work from home and already have a child need more bedrooms and at least two bathrooms. Fink doesn't disagree, but notes that unless the parents are hiding a trust fund, this is what the couple can afford. When Fink mentions the commute into the city, the parents insist the distance is far too great.

Sethi's response is blunt: stop looking for your parents' approval on housing and financial decisions. Sethi brings up their own background, noting that Indian families are known for seeking parental approval on everything, and still says "stop it." Sethi then asks for some sympathy for the parents. Their view of housing was formed in a world so different from today's that, in Sethi's assessment, it is "effectively impossible" for them to understand the current market. Sethi compares it to a coworker you eventually realize you can't convince because their worldview is too different, so you stop trying.

The practical point is about who bears the consequences. Sethi asks whether the parents will pay the bills or help with anything. If not, sending them listings and defending your preferences only causes you heartache. The phrase Sethi returns to is that it is "your rich life," not your parents'.

3:02

What a Dorm Room Reveals About Needs and Identity

Sethi then turns to the reactions of older, wealthier people when they see how young people live. Sethi mentions a widely shared photo of Hillary Clinton walking through a small apartment with a tiny kitchen, wearing a look of shock. Sethi says they get the reaction, and recalls watching obviously wealthy parents drop their children off at college dorms. Even at Stanford, which Sethi says had good dorms compared to other colleges, a room was about 10 by 10 feet and housed two or three students. To an adult used to a 2,800- or 4,000-square-foot house, that looks impossible.

Sethi's takeaway is that most people don't need everything they think they need, whether four and a half bathrooms or radiant floor heating. Sethi also explains why giving those things up feels so painful. As a personal example, Sethi says that being forced to give up nice pens for cheap scratchy ones would leave them seriously wondering where they went wrong in life, and possibly "emotionally devastated." If a pen can feel like that, imagine a 58- or 68-year-old who barely enters three of their bedrooms more than once a year but insists they need them. The house has become part of their identity.

In Sethi's view, Americans attach identity to a few purchases above all: first the house, second the car, and to some extent, third, food. Being told you can't buy Kraft macaroni and cheese anymore and must buy Safeway's generic version would, Sethi suggests, devastate many people, however foolish that sounds. In a consumer society, what we buy often confers identity. Sethi's own work on the "rich life" argues the opposite: you choose what defines you. Sethi hopes viewers manage their expenses well enough that they never have to step down socioeconomically, but believes most people could do it if they had to.

6:59

The $3,000 Car Offer and the $30,000 Jeep

In the next clip, the poster says their father inherited a lot of money after his wife died and offered to buy them a car. The poster had been keeping an old beater running and sent links to used cars with lower mileage in decent condition. Everything they sent looked unbelievably expensive to the father, who said he wanted to spend $2,000 or $3,000. The poster explained that amount wouldn't even buy a beater as good as the one they already had. The father thought this was ridiculous, withdrew the offer, and bought himself a $30,000 Jeep.

Sethi's two comments are that this is a "horrible dad" and that the Jeep was a bad choice. Sethi refers to videos in which mechanics are asked which cars keep coming into the shop. In Sethi's telling, the answers are usually Jeep and Mercedes, while the mechanics themselves drive a Honda or a Toyota. With an inheritance, Sethi says, the father could have bought something more reliable or more beautiful.

7:54

Walking In With a Printed Résumé

A satirical clip lays out "how to get a job according to Boomers": print your résumé on the best paper you can find, deliver it in person because applying online is for lazy people, and demand to see the hiring manager until you're offered the job. The sketch ends with the job seeker being told that isn't how it works.

Sethi uses this to raise a broader question: does anyone ever react well to being told they're out of touch? Sethi points to people married for 50 years who hand out dating advice, and to parenting advice that ignores how much technology and norms have changed. Sethi says they don't think they've ever told someone this to their face and want to try it. Sethi imagines how the conversation might go. The other person would say good principles last forever. You would ask whether medical students trained in 1970 learned the same techniques used today, and they'd agree that medicine has adapted. Sethi predicts they still won't connect that to careers, so you'd have to ask directly whether things might have changed in the past 38 years. Sethi half-jokingly asks viewers to film the moment someone realizes they may not understand today's job market and send in the videos.

10:22

The $150 Grocery Claim and the Value of Curiosity

A post from the X user UziCryptoo says their Boomer dad claimed he could buy a month of groceries for a family of four with $150. Sethi says they've floated an idea to their team: meet the people making these claims and have them actually try it. Sethi jokes that the father probably hasn't cracked an egg in decades.

Sethi describes another video in which an older woman guesses it costs $20 to fill a gas tank and is told it's $60. Sethi admits being out of touch too: Sethi doesn't buy milk and doesn't know what a gallon costs. The difference, Sethi argues, is admitting it and getting curious. Ask what it costs, what it cost historically, and how people manage. What frustrates Sethi is the 75-year-old who, instead of getting curious, insists "that can't be" and claims they could do it themselves, despite never having done it even at 25.

11:50

Eating Out: Ramit's "Multiply by Three" Rule

Here Sethi partly sides with the older generation. A clip mocks the idea that millennials and Gen Z would be out of debt if they just ate at home. Sethi agrees that this gets made fun of, but says many people really do eat out too much and don't want to hear it.

Sethi describes what they call "Ramit's magic number of eating out." Eating out includes coffee, lunch, dinner, and even stopping at a gas station for beef jerky. When Sethi asks people how often they eat out, the true number is roughly three times what they say. Sethi plays a clip from an earlier session to show the same pattern with travel. A guest estimates about three vacations a year, and on reflection says they took about 10 the previous year. Sethi says the rule applies to both eating out and vacations and claims "it never fails." When someone says they eat out about five times a week, Sethi walks through each meal of each day, weekends included, and the total almost always comes to 15, 16, or 17.

13:16

The Three Big Categories of Overspending

Sethi names three categories where people overspend. The first is housing. Sethi acknowledges that housing is historically expensive, but says people buy homes based on gut feeling rather than calculation. The second is cars, which are also expensive, and people rarely work out the total cost of ownership. The third is eating out, where Sethi says people undercount "by more than half."

If you don't know your housing costs as a percentage of your gross income, or haven't heard of the 28/36 rule, Sethi says you have work to do. Sethi recommends their book and encourages viewers to take control of what they can control. Sethi stresses that this doesn't rule out criticizing your parents: you can still roast your Boomer parents, but you should take control of your own finances. Sethi adds that nearly everyone has advice for you, even people who know nothing about your situation, but you are the one who lives with the consequences. That is why Sethi says random people's opinions "bounce right off" and what matters is results.

15:49

Millennial Parents and America's "Toxic Individualism"

A clip from Josh Benson argues that millennial parents are exhausted because whenever they ask their own parents for help with the kids, they're told "we did it on our own, life's hard, figure it out," even though the Boomer generation often had extra childcare support.

Sethi sees this as reflecting a "toxic strain of individualism" in American culture. Sethi says rugged individualism is so deeply embedded that Americans can't see an alternative until they travel. Sethi gives two examples: seeing families abroad sharing a large dinner and thinking it seems nice, and a recent trip to Tokyo. There, Sethi observed that people stay completely silent on trains, and on rainy days everyone seals their umbrellas before boarding, so there is effectively no water on the subway floor. Sethi attributes this to collectivist care for the people around you. Americans admire it in theory, Sethi says, then come home and tell each other to pull themselves up because "I did it." Admiring collectivist cultures on the surface while refusing to question our own, in Sethi's view, leaves Americans in "the worst of all worlds."

Sethi extends this to rights. America is built on personal rights, but Sethi argues those rights are frequently violated: property owners can't build what they want on their own land, and women lost protections they had under Roe v. Wade. Sethi argues that Americans often love the idea of individual rights more than they love a society that would actually serve them better. Sethi cites the book Dying of Whiteness, which Sethi says discusses how people prize the right to bear arms even though Americans die from gun violence at very high rates compared to other countries. When the issue is raised, Sethi says, people answer that it's about rights and refuse to discuss what kind of rights we should have.

18:45

Send Your Parents Grocery Shopping and Put Them on Reality TV

A clip from MotherPhyllis features a parody parent scolding young people for spending too much on "frivolous things" like groceries and rent. Sethi proposes what they call the most entertaining test: ask an out-of-touch parent to do your grocery shopping once. If they think a month of groceries costs $400, hand them $200 for two weeks. Sethi predicts they'll buy the brand names they're used to, such as Ritz crackers and Cheez-Its, which Sethi says now cost far more than they remember, and that around 40% of the budget will be gone after one aisle. Sethi jokes about photographing the parent's horrified face with a 200mm lens and posting it on their garage, then wonders aloud whether that's healthy.

The next clip, from Mike Mancusi, proposes a reality show in which Boomers are put through leaving college, finding a job, and buying a house under 2026 conditions rather than 1975 conditions. Sethi likes the idea and says they're going to text the showrunner of their Netflix show. Sethi then doubts retirees would sign up, joking that when you ask retirees about their lives, they say things are slower and breakfast doesn't happen until 11:15. Sethi invites Boomers willing to participate, and adult children who want to "involuntarily submit" their parents, to comment.

21:04

Two Teachers on a Lake: How Housing Became Unattainable

The most substantial clip comes from Lauren Palmieri, whose parents are retired public school teachers and younger Boomers. In the 1990s, with two children, Palmieri's parents bought a three-bedroom house on a lake, complete with a boat. It wasn't fancy, but it was on the water. Palmieri reports that two houses currently for sale on the same lake are listed at $530,000 and $1.2 million, and asks viewers to imagine what a household of two public school teachers with two kids could afford today.

Sethi calls that purchase impossible for two public school teachers now. Sethi mentions a recurring internet story: neighborhoods where long-time residents were ordinary workers, such as a former mail carrier and an insurance company employee, and the only people who can now afford to move in are two high-powered corporate attorneys. Sethi sarcastically suggests that this is how America achieves neighborhood "diversity": older homeowners who have kept property values high by blocking new housing, alongside wealthy newcomers.

Sethi then explains how they think this happened. Ordinary people with ordinary jobs, sometimes on one income, could once afford homes. Once they owned, Sethi argues, they "pulled up the drawbridge" and voted for local politicians who blocked new housing, citing traffic or infrastructure. Sethi says it has become increasingly absurd, pointing to people who sue cities because a proposed building would cast a shadow on their house for 1.2 hours a day. Sethi's principle is that buying a home gives you rights to your property, not the right to preserve your neighborhood "in amber."

Sethi calls these people NIMBYs ("not in my backyard"), says they hate NIMBYs, and calls them one of the worst groups in America, numbering in the tens of millions. Sethi also says NIMBYs aren't necessarily evil. They are your parents, your neighbors, maybe you. In Sethi's account, people "magically" become NIMBYs once they buy a home, regardless of whether they are liberal or conservative.

Sethi grants that NIMBYism is rational in a narrow sense. For many Americans, the home is their main source of net worth, so restricting supply pushes its value up. But Sethi argues that NIMBYs end up harming themselves. Young families can't move in, the neighborhood ages into what Sethi calls a "geriatric facility," and cafés and restaurants don't want to open. Later, when owners find their big house hard to clean and maintain and want something smaller, perhaps single-floor housing suited to mobility issues, those options don't exist. Sethi says people don't connect their own NIMBYism to the shortage of two-bedroom apartments and single-floor homes, and end up moving to Florida, a destination Sethi mocks.

Sethi concludes from the lake example that what two middle-class Americans could do 30 years ago is impossible today. Sethi estimates that two middle-class earners would now struggle for 15 or more years just to save a down payment on a $1 million house. So Sethi rejects "in my day I did it, just work harder": the structure has changed, and Sethi tells homeowners in the audience that they are probably partly responsible.

25:44

Invisible Money Scripts

Sethi closes by turning the critique back on the viewer. Even people who roll their eyes at Boomer advice often still believe parts of it. Sethi gives two examples: "I should pay off all my debt before I invest because debt is bad," and "I need to buy a house as soon as possible because I'm throwing money away on rent." Sethi calls these "invisible money scripts": beliefs heard so often that people stop noticing or questioning them, even as the beliefs shape their financial lives.

Sethi's challenge is simple. The next time you hold a strong opinion about money, ask yourself where you learned it. You may find you're acting on advice handed down decades ago that worked for someone else in a very different time. In Sethi's framing, the people who get ahead financially aren't those who follow rules blindly, but those who can tell which rules still make sense today and which ones to discard.