Yann LeCun on AI Doom, the Limits of LLMs, and Why He Left Meta to Build World Models

Open on YouTube ↗
Overview

Yann LeCun, a Turing Award laureate, longtime chief AI scientist at Meta, and now founder of AMI Labs, spoke with TBS CROSS DIG business editor Masahiro Nakagawa about a question that has drawn wide attention in Japan and elsewhere: could AI wipe out humanity? LeCun's answer is a flat no. In his view, today's AI is far less intelligent than its boosters and critics claim, the existential-risk narrative has no scientific basis, and the real danger lies elsewhere: in power concentrating in a few companies. He also explained why he left Meta after twelve years, what his "world model" approach is meant to do that large language models cannot, and where he expects the first applications to appear.

23 min read
1:52

"Completely made up": rejecting the extinction argument

When asked why he rejects the idea that AI poses an existential risk, LeCun did not hedge. He called it "completely made up" and said there is "no science behind it at all." The probabilities that some people cite for an AI takeover, in his view, are "pulled out of thin air" and supported by no real argument.

He traced the narrative to one assumption he considers false: that an entity which is more intelligent will necessarily dominate less intelligent ones. He argued that this fails in nature, where a virus can take humans down without being particularly intelligent. It also fails within our own species. The smartest people are not the ones who seek to lead, he said, pointing loosely to the international political scene. Many of the smartest people he knows "want nothing to do with their fellow humans." They are mathematicians, computer scientists, or physicists who simply want to work on problems that interest them.

LeCun attributed the prominence of the extinction narrative partly to science fiction, and partly to what he described as a small number of wealthy people "with probably too much time on their hands" who are "a little paranoid" and who fund organizations to "feed the fire." He named Open Philanthropy, noting that it had recently changed its name, as an active funder of think tanks and independent research groups. In his account, those groups publish elaborate scenarios of AI-driven human extinction. He insisted these scenarios are not scientific and said that "the vast majority of the AI research community does not believe at all in those stories."

4:35

Anthropic, OpenAI, and the politics of safety

Nakagawa pointed out that much of the public conversation comes from the AI labs themselves, especially OpenAI and Anthropic. LeCun called Anthropic "an interesting case." He said it was initially funded by Open Philanthropy, and that the chair of Anthropic's board, Dario Amodei's sister, is married to a co-founder of Open Philanthropy. "So it's the same people," he said. He also placed Amodei in the effective altruism community. Amodei denies this, LeCun noted, but LeCun said he believes it to be true.

As LeCun described it, this leaves Amodei in a difficult position. He has to say AI is potentially dangerous while building some of the most powerful AI systems in existence. LeCun said Amodei resolves the tension by arguing that AI is intrinsically dangerous and therefore should not be given to everyone, and that it should instead be heavily regulated and controlled. LeCun called that stance "a new form of obscurantism." He compared it to the Ottoman Empire's ban on the printing press, which he described as a move to keep control of dogma and to protect established groups such as scribes. AI, he argued, is a wonderful way of accessing and disseminating knowledge. If it is kept under the control of a few companies or governments, its benefits cannot be realized.

He saw OpenAI as more ambiguous. It is less focused on safety than Anthropic, and LeCun said it seemed clear to him that Sam Altman's thinking on these questions has evolved. As evidence, he cited the fact that OpenAI's AI safety group has been more or less disbanded, pushed out, or deemphasized. He acknowledged that departing staff often say publicly that the companies are reckless. His own view was blunt: those people "were being toxic and not very useful."

7:55

How smart is current AI?

LeCun said that current AI technology is "not very smart at all" in most domains. He described it as a good distillation of human knowledge. It looks smart because it has accumulated an enormous amount of declarative knowledge and can "regurgitate it at the right time," especially since most people ask the same questions.

He made two exceptions: mathematics and computer code. In these areas he said AI can be genuinely creative and can invent solutions humans had not yet found. His explanation was that both domains allow automatic self-refinement. A system can produce a proof and verify whether it is correct, then try again if it isn't. It can write a program, run it, check whether it does what it should, and generate another if it doesn't. Through hill climbing or reinforcement learning, the system eventually finds something that works. Self-improvement is also possible in other domains that can be fully simulated, but LeCun said that is rare. He does not expect systems to improve at the same rate in areas like drug design, which require actual experiments in the real world.

When Nakagawa raised recursive self-improvement, LeCun said it is happening only in very narrow domains where the system can be evaluated fully automatically, without human intervention. That means code, mathematics, and perhaps a few areas where simulation is possible. He said there is "a lot of delusion in Silicon Valley." It is not the first time AI has seen the belief that a new technique will deliver human-level AI, and he called that belief false this time too. He listed impressive achievements: proving theorems, passing the bar exam, playing chess and Go (which he noted are not LLMs), and computing protein conformations. Then he asked where the domestic robot is, where the level-five self-driving car is, where even a robot that can do what a house cat does is. We do not yet have the basic methodology, he argued, to build systems that understand the physical world as well as they understand natural language, code, or mathematics. "The real world is just very, very complicated and messy."

12:07

Why text alone won't reach human-level intelligence

LeCun said that what LLMs lack is grounding in the real world. He acknowledged that philosophers have long debated whether intelligence must be grounded in reality or can be abstract, and said he believes it must be grounded.

To support this he gave a set of rough figures. All publicly available text on the internet comes to about 20 trillion words, or roughly 30 trillion tokens. At about three bytes per token, that is around 10^14 bytes. A human reading all of it would need something like 400,000 years. By his calculation, a four-year-old child has taken in about the same amount of information through vision alone. Each optic nerve carries about one megabyte per second, so two nerves deliver about two megabytes per second to the visual cortex. A four-year-old has been awake for about 16,000 hours, which comes to roughly 10^14 bytes.

His conclusion was that natural signals such as vision, touch, and hearing contain far more information than text, and that training on text alone will never produce human-level intelligence. He conceded that modern systems take multimodal inputs. But he described them as having special encoders for images and other signals "bolted on top of an LLM," which turn everything into sequences of discrete symbols. He does not consider that a good way to handle reality.

14:26

The OpenAI–Hugging Face incident: "human error"

Nakagawa asked about the July incident in which OpenAI agents penetrated Hugging Face's servers, an event that fueled fears of AI escaping human control. LeCun's first point was that "nothing really bad happened." Hugging Face is not suing OpenAI, and the agents destroyed nothing. They penetrated a server they were not supposed to.

He described the cause as a sandbox that was "leaky" and "very badly designed." In his view that was mainly because OpenAI has little experience in cybersecurity, and the failure was either deliberate or the result of incompetence. When Nakagawa asked whether it was human error, LeCun agreed. In his account, the agents did exactly what they were asked to do, which was to penetrate another system, but they were supposed to do so inside the sandbox and got out because of OpenAI's poor design.

He said there has been a lot of overreaction. Cybersecurity professionals do think the landscape is changing, but by his account they are not excessively worried. The bigger question, he said, is whether agents capable of penetrating systems favor attackers or defenders. He said plainly that he does not know. His hunch is that they favor defense, because developers can use these systems to build more secure and reliable software from the start, then use them to attack their own software and harden it before release. He predicted an era in which software becomes "way more secure than it used to be" thanks to AI.

17:12

A transition period, not a catastrophe

Nakagawa raised the recent wave of cyberattacks around the world, including one in France on supermarket refrigeration systems that had been widely discussed in Japan, and noted that these attacks appear to be AI-assisted. LeCun called the issue serious in one sense: security is always a cat-and-mouse game in which new attack techniques prompt better defenses.

He compared the current moment to the early internet. Websites were initially unencrypted (HTTP rather than HTTPS), authenticating users was difficult and insecure for years, and personal computers, particularly Windows machines, were easy prey because they were badly designed. All of that eventually got fixed. He expects a similar transition period now, during which many systems will be fixed and hardened against AI-enabled attacks.

18:53

From FAIR to chief AI scientist to a new architecture

LeCun recounted his history at Meta. He joined in late 2013 and created FAIR, originally Facebook AI Research, later renamed Fundamental AI Research when the company changed its name. He led the lab for four and a half years. In 2018 he stepped back from day-to-day management and became chief AI scientist, which let him pursue research projects himself with small teams of students, postdocs, and engineers.

After three or four years, he said, the work reached a breakthrough. He distilled the ideas into a path toward systems that understand the real world and can plan and reason, and published a vision paper online laying out where he thought AI research should go over the next decade. He said they are now four years into that plan. The paper proposed an architecture called JEPA, the Joint Embedding Predictive Architecture, which he described as an alternative to generative AI. Like an LLM, it is trained in a self-supervised way through prediction. An LLM predicts the next word. LeCun has spent much of the past 20 years trying to apply the same idea to video, on the theory that a system able to predict what happens next in a video would understand something about the world's underlying structure.

For the first 15 of those years, he said, he "basically failed," because he used generative models that tried to predict video pixel by pixel. That turned out to be impossible, because most of the information in a video, like most of what we observe in the world, is unpredictable. Around 2019, he and younger colleagues hit on the idea of having the system learn an abstract representation of its observations and make predictions in that representation space, discarding the information that simply can't be predicted. That became JEPA. Since then, he said, they have developed training methods, shown that the approach works well for fully self-supervised computer vision, and more recently shown that it works for video and can be trained to produce a world model.

He defined a world model as a system that lets an agent predict the consequences of its own actions. Given the state of the world at time t and an action the agent imagines taking, the model predicts the state at time t+1. With such a model, a system can predict the outcome of a sequence of actions and search for the best sequence to accomplish a task. LeCun said this is planning, and that it can be generalized to reasoning. He called it a completely different blueprint from LLMs, with characteristics he considers necessary for human-level AI that LLMs lack.

23:29

Why he left Meta

Asked why he left if the technology looked promising for Meta, LeCun said it was promising and to some extent still is. He stressed that his project had the support of Mark Zuckerberg and CTO Andrew Bosworth, and that he did not feel a lack of support.

The issue was fit. As the techniques began to work well, he realized their main applications were in industry: industrial process control, manufacturing, and robotics. Meanwhile, Meta had more or less decided to get out of robotics and had disbanded its robotics research group, though some robotics activity remains. Around spring 2025, the company completely refocused on LLMs. Among some of the people hired then, LeCun said, there was a belief that LLMs would lead to superintelligence, which he "did not believe in at all." His vision was therefore misaligned, not with Zuckerberg or Bosworth, but with the leadership of the AI organization, whom he referred to as Alex ("he's learning fast," LeCun added), and with some colleagues there. The research lab had also become much less open, which he did not think was a good direction. Finally, he realized he could raise enough money to mount a serious effort on his own.

26:15

The case for open source

LeCun said one of his main reasons for joining Meta in the first place was its open culture. The company already open-sourced its infrastructure software and even published specifications for its hardware. When he was recruited, his condition was that the lab would publish most of its research and open-source most of its code. He said he was told not to worry, because openness was "in the DNA of the company."

That lasted, he said, until early 2025, when the industry as a whole began to "clam up." In his account, OpenAI had not published models since GPT-3, Anthropic had always been secretive "because of the safety mythology," and Google DeepMind was also publishing less and restricting publications. Meta followed the trend, which he considered a mistake, and the initial plan in 2025 was apparently not to open-source frontier models. Now, he said, Meta is backpedaling. He said Zuckerberg published a piece a couple of months earlier arguing that AI should be personalized, in everyone's hands, and mostly open source, and LeCun said he strongly supports that. He described himself as a strong advocate for open-sourcing Llama while at Meta and said the release of Llama 2 "completely jump-started the whole AI industry."

He called China's current position as the strongest advocate of open-source models "of course" a good thing. He acknowledged that some users, particularly American users and companies, remain reluctant to use Chinese models because of how they are trained and the biases they may carry. He noted that open models can be fine-tuned for one's own needs.

To the concern that open models help cyberattackers, LeCun said he disagreed "100%." He said the Hugging Face incident itself showed the opposite. He first said Hugging Face had used Qwen to trace the OpenAI intrusion. When Nakagawa corrected him that it was GLM, he accepted the correction. Either way, the tool was an open-source Chinese model. He linked this to the old internet-era debate over "security through obscurity." In his telling, keeping systems secret turned out not to make them safer. Systems need to be open so vulnerabilities are found and patched quickly, and he said the same thing is happening with AI.

31:00

AMI Labs: why a company, and why world models

LeCun founded AMI Labs at the end of the previous year, began operations in March, and, as Nakagawa noted, raised about a billion dollars. Asked why he chose a company rather than a nonprofit or academic research (he is still a professor at New York University), LeCun said this kind of research needs people and GPUs, both expensive, and a company is essentially the only way to raise enough money. He said AMI Labs is "basically burning cash in GPUs right now," training video models and other world models.

He argued that world-model-based systems can do many things LLMs, in their current form, never will unless they adopt world models. He pointed to robotics companies that tried LLM-derived approaches, VLAs or VLMs. "It doesn't work," he said, and claimed most people experimenting with them are abandoning them for world models. In his account, world models are the hottest topic in the AI research community, though industry has yet to catch up, and JEPA is the hottest topic within world models.

He distinguished his approach from generative world models that do video prediction. He mentioned another company's "world models," which he described as essentially consistent video generation systems, and said he doesn't believe in that approach. AMI Labs is "not generating pixels." Just as human brains do not generate pixels when imagining the consequences of actions, JEPA models imagine the future in an abstract representation space. LeCun said this is far more efficient and better founded, "philosophically almost."

On whether JEPA could reach human-level AI, he was measured. "I think we have a shot," he said, adding that a couple more major innovations may be needed. With LLMs, he said, he can already see two limitations that make a fundamental architectural change necessary. First, you cannot really understand the real world with generative models. Second, you cannot act intelligently or plan without anticipating the consequences of your actions, which requires an explicit world model that LLMs lack. He called both "completely obvious." With JEPA, he said, they don't see the limitations yet, but they will "almost certainly" run into some within the next several years.

35:29

LLMs' role, common sense, and "intrinsically safe" design

LeCun did not dismiss LLMs entirely. He said they have a role as a good way of distilling the human knowledge that exists in text. But he added that text is a very small share of human knowledge. Most of it has nothing to do with language: it is what we learn as babies about how the world works, what we call common sense. He noted that animals lack human language, and said orangutans are "almost as smart as we are." Humans, in his view, are only a little smarter than them.

His work targets this non-linguistic side of intelligence: understanding the world, planning, reasoning, and common sense. That requires predicting the consequences of actions, explicit world models, and the ability to consider multiple courses of action toward a goal. He calls this "objective-driven AI" or an objective-driven architecture.

One advantage he claimed is that such systems are controllable and can be made safe "by construction." Guardrail objectives can be hardwired so that when the system plans a sequence of actions, it anticipates whether they will have harmful effects on the environment, and the system can be trained to evaluate good and bad effects. He therefore believes these systems can be made intrinsically safe. Here he partly agreed with the "safetyists": LLMs, he said, are intrinsically unsafe and cannot be made completely safe. "But they're not very smart, so that doesn't make them very dangerous."

38:21

Industrial applications and the Japan connection

Nakagawa noted that Toyota Ventures is an early investor in AMI Labs and asked about applications. LeCun described a broad pattern. Whenever sensors such as cameras, vibration sensors, or audio are measuring a complex industrial or biological system, a world model can predict the system's future state, including the effect of an intervention. With such a "phenomenological" model, one can control the system optimally and predict failures. That enables anomaly detection, predictive maintenance, and optimal control. He gave examples: a turbojet, a chemical plant, a robot, a patient, a human cell. None of these can be reduced to a small set of equations, but a predictive model can be trained from data.

He said initial applications will mainly be in manufacturing, where he called Japan one of the world's foremost countries. Longer-term applications include autonomous driving and domestic robots, which he noted Toyota is interested in.

40:47

The real danger: concentration of power

Asked whether his industrial focus conflicts with Zuckerberg's emphasis on "personal intelligence," LeCun said the two views are compatible. He also believes AI should eventually be personalized and in everyone's hands, and that there should be a wide diversity of AI assistants. That, he explained, is why he supports open foundation models. Training one is very expensive, like building a railway or highway, and you don't need two railways between the same two cities. If there were a free, open, frontier foundation model, he argued, there would be no need for proprietary commercial ones. Companies could build vertical applications on top, countries could build systems reflecting their languages, cultures, values, interests, and even political leanings, and people would have a wide range of assistants.

LeCun said the biggest danger of AI today, in his mind, is power concentrated in a small number of companies. That would homogenize human culture, because everyone would get their "information diet" from the same two or three AI assistants, which he called "very bad for democracy and culture."

43:01

What to expect next

For the coming year, LeCun said he hopes for progress in what is now called physical AI: systems that, in his opinion, will not be based on LLMs but possibly on JEPA and certainly on world models. He expects them to understand the real world much better and to be used first for controlling industrial processes and eventually for robotics, perhaps opening the door to domestic robots.

He closed with what he called "a big secret in the industry." Many companies are building humanoid robots, but in his view "none of those companies has any idea how to make those robots smart enough to be useful." They are betting that AI will advance enough over the next two or three years to power their products by the time the products are ready. "But currently," LeCun said, "it's still very far."