Henning Lundkvist on Art, Money, and Planned Obsolescence — A Retrospective
Fundación Juan MarchThe Fundación Juan March in Palma runs a series called "Las economías del arte" (The Economies of Art). It looks at how artistic creation connects to the fact that artists, like anyone else, have to earn a living. The second session centered on Planned Obsolescence — A Retrospective by the Copenhagen-based writer Henning Lundkvist. The book is now appearing in Spanish for the first time, published by Nagi bookz with the Fundación Juan March, alongside an exhibition the organizers said would be on view at the foundation's Madrid headquarters between October 2026 and January 2027. Lundkvist spoke with Pablo Pérez d'Ors about how the book came about, why it approaches art through economics, and whether anything can be done about the problems it describes. Lundkvist's position, stated with consistent dry humor, is that the book deliberately follows one flawed perspective to its end. It was never meant as a verdict on how art should work or as a reason to stop making it.
The format of the evening
The host explained that the event had an unusual structure. It opened with a conversation of about half an hour in English, with Spanish subtitles projected above the stage. After a break for a glass of wine, the audience would return for readings from the Spanish translation and an open discussion of the book's content. For that reason, the interviewer said they would avoid going into the book's details during the conversation and focus instead on how Lundkvist came to write it.
The introduction described Lundkvist as living in Copenhagen and calling himself "a writer, librarian, and occasionally an artist." Besides writing about other artists' work and exhibitions, he teaches and occasionally shows his own work. Planned Obsolescence — A Retrospective first appeared in English in 2018, and he has published several other titles since. He founded a publishing company called Inaktiv, which was also the title of his solo retrospective at the Vermilion Sands Gallery in Copenhagen in 2023. Lundkvist responded that this was "basically everything I've ever done."
A book that grew out of a single sentence
Lundkvist described himself as someone who does "a bit too many different things at the same time," and said the book was one project among many. The occasion for publishing it was an exhibition in Porto in 2018. The first edition came out through Gonçalo, who was in the audience and co-designed the book with Lundkvist.
The idea itself, he said, did not come from that exhibition. It came from the book's opening sentence: "It is true that I had accumulated a lot of cultural capital but I had never managed to convert it into cash." He found the sentence "both very stupid but also very true," and decided to see whether he could write a whole book by simply following that line wherever it led.
The writing happened in bursts. He would sit down for a weekend and produce thirty pages. Then weeks would pass without any time to write, followed by a few more sentences. He had recently moved to Copenhagen and was working in a bar most of the time, so he was, as he put it, busy "with a lot of stuff that has to do with life."
A PhD with a "100% hit factor"
Asked how his life has changed since, Lundkvist said that, somewhat ironically for someone who wrote a book about money and art, he is now "in a slightly better position" financially. He is doing a PhD at the library of the Design Museum Denmark, on its historical collection. That means he writes a fair amount, but for an audience he estimated at perhaps ten people, or five if the PhD doesn't go well.
He treated this as a continuation of his whole adult life, which he said has been spent on niche work for small audiences, ever since he played in a punk band at thirteen. The difference now, he joked, is that everyone who could possibly care about the subject will probably read his thesis, so in that sense it is "a full 100% hit factor."
The collection itself dates from the late nineteenth century. It was assembled as inspiration for designers and craftsmen and contains around 50,000 prints and photographs of door handles, ceilings, frescoes and similar things. He called it "a Pinterest or Google image search from the late 19th century."
Feeling the economy in your body
The interviewer pointed out that the book is autobiographical but also takes a broader interest in economics, and asked whether that interest came from economics as such or from the need to make a living. Lundkvist answered that "as an artist you really feel economy." Put diplomatically, he said, every artist feels it physically. Those who make it big feel it too, just differently.
He would not call this an interest in economics as a discipline. He has always been drawn to "what is behind things": the structures and connections between them. In art, that means the institutions and the conditions under which art gets shown. He said that he generally found even "the walk to the Kunsthalle" more interesting than what was inside it. Economics became interesting to him because, to a certain extent, it defines so much of what can happen. He described the relationship as double, though, because "so much happens despite economy" as well.
Talking about money, and growing tired of it
The interviewer noted that the art world can treat money as something dirty and avoid discussing it, as though artists were pure beings existing on their own, which plainly isn't true. Lundkvist agreed that the book is very much about having a hard time making ends meet and paying rent. It was also written in a way that speaks to many people in the same situation, so in that sense it has a target audience.
That had a side effect. For several years people wanted to talk to him about the book constantly, and he "got rather fed up." He had written it to get these thoughts out of his head, not so that everyone would tell him they felt the same and that "we have to talk about money." He did agree that there is something in the art world that keeps money from being discussed much. When it is discussed, he said, the conversation tends to be about the very top, such as the most expensive works ever sold. It is rarely about "how does this whole thing actually work or doesn't work."
Pessimistic, realistic, or neither?
Trying not to give spoilers, the interviewer suggested that part of the book's conclusion is that the system basically doesn't work, and that its flaws are widespread rather than unique to Lundkvist. That would make the book pessimistic, or perhaps realistic.
Lundkvist said he didn't think it was that pessimistic, partly because it contains humor. Everyone should read it, he said, "to see how fun it can be when something doesn't work economically." For him the more important point was using something as material. The "very boring economic situation" and the heavy pressure on him as a younger artist could be turned into a new work, which is the book itself. Some of it may be pessimistic, but other parts say that this situation can provide material for something else. He conceded that the book "doesn't paint a very happy picture of the state of the world." The interviewer replied that it contains humor and, as far as they could see, no self-pity.
Punk bass and a form without full stops
Returning to the punk band, the interviewer asked what role Lundkvist had played in it. His first answer was that the band rehearsed in his garage, which made him "landlord, I guess." He played bass. He tried most other instruments too but said he wasn't very good at anything else. He grew up in a very musical family where instruments were always around. He isn't sure he thought of the band as punk at the time, but it probably was, and he moved into much more experimental music quite early: "I was lost already at an early age."
The interviewer linked this to the book's form, which they found hard to classify. Lundkvist calls it a novel at one point, and it can be read that way. Its repetitions, pace and rhythm, along with the complete absence of full stops, also make it read like slam poetry, hip-hop or pop lyrics. And in some ways it is more essay than novel.
Lundkvist said the label wasn't very important to him. The book has a protagonist who closely resembled him at the time of writing. Calling it a novel, however, grants certain freedoms, such as dropping full stops. More importantly, he does not agree with everything in it. He saw that as a major difference from an essay. In a work of fiction or autofiction, you can start from a sentence and see what happens.
Following a logic until art loses
He described the method as an experiment. You try to explain art through economics, through the eyes of a young struggling artist, and you keep that perspective until it reaches book length. "It's a short book, but it's still a book." Doing this means following the logic of something rather than your own ideas about how the world works.
The consequence, in his view, is built in: if you follow art through the economy, "art is always going to lose. Because economy wins." He called that the sad part. Seen only from an economic point of view, art ends up on the losing side. This is why he says the perspective itself is flawed. He does not claim it is the best way to explain how art or the art world works. It is one way of looking, and the book asks what comes out of following it.
He described two kinds of reactions from readers, including artist peers and audiences at his readings. Some relate to the book and find it interesting. Others tell him it is so depressing they had to stop reading, "because otherwise, I will stop making art." He said he did not write it to make people stop. When the interviewer pointed out that he himself hasn't stopped, he answered, "I don't make that much," but added that he doesn't want other people to stop.
Too much of everything
The interviewer raised one of the book's central concerns: inflation, in the sense that there is too much art. Lundkvist agreed there is too much, but said that is true of everything, not specifically of contemporary art. The interviewer offered "contemporary life," and he accepted the phrase.
He also said the complaint is not new. For his PhD he is reading a book about information management systems from the 1500s, in which people were already complaining that there were too many books, even though by today's standards "there wasn't that much really." Complaining that there is too much of things is a continuous complaint, he said, "but it doesn't make it less true, I guess."
An aftertaste, or a spray
The interviewer described their own reaction. Finishing the book felt like leaving a long, ambitious, complex film with the soundtrack still in their head. They suggested the book captures the song you hum after taking in contemporary art: the flavor that remains after digesting something huge and difficult. Lundkvist checked whether they meant the book itself had that flavor, and when they said yes, he called it "a nice way" of putting it, "a smell."
He said he has collected, over the years, things other people say about his work, including things he disagrees with. A friend once described much of what he does as "like a spray." It comes into the room, stays for a while, and then disappears. Lundkvist suggested this book might be that spray: the result of processing everything that comes in, passing it through the computer, and putting out a book.
The tourists who review the book
The interviewer read a passage they found especially funny. In it, a group of tourists on a tour describe the book itself: "Planned Obsolescence — A Retrospective, a book that broke the taboo of speaking about the storing of unsold works of art. The book is by no means a masterpiece, but it is an important document of its time and its popularity paved the way for thousands of new storage facilities for art."
Lundkvist replied, "Let's see if it happens." He pointed out that the book is in its third English edition and first Spanish one, so "it keeps booming," and the prophecy could still come true.
Breaking things when young, and who rebuilds
The interviewer then asked about solutions. They referred to a cynical aside in the book: youth and idealism push people to break the art world, or whatever came before, but when young people break things, it is not the young who get to rebuild. It is the powerful. How, they asked, can broken or malfunctioning things be rebuilt?
Lundkvist, after asking "Did I write that?", called it a very big question and said that having written the line didn't mean he could answer it. "I take no responsibility for what's in that book," he added. He connected the passage to his youth: music, and the illegal downloading scene, which many of his friends were deeply involved in. He jokingly added that he himself "of course" never did anything of the sort.
What the passage refers to, he said, is a rather naive idea of the internet in the early 2000s: being free and open, "information wants to be free." What came out of it in the end was Spotify and Google. He said things have not improved since he wrote the book in 2018. Compared with the large-scale AI developments happening now, he called Spotify "a very small and cute little actor."
He described this as a pattern that has happened before. When you are young, you often want to break an institution because you want something different. But if an institution that actually worked ends up "completely smashed and everything becomes privatized," then that "was maybe not the best thing that could happen." He did not offer a solution beyond that observation.
Museums and the value of being slow
The interviewer's last question was about museums. Asked whether he is a museum-goer, Lundkvist noted that he works in one and goes there every day. He does visit museums, but is not a "museum buff" who goes to everything.
The interviewer asked whether museums and public art spaces could present art differently from the art market. Lundkvist said they can, and should. In his experience, the art and culture he finds interesting first appears in a basement or a small artist-run or musician-run venue. Some of it later moves into commercial galleries and some doesn't. Museums generally come later still, and he sees that as part of their role. A museum isn't necessarily supposed to be fast, since plenty of other things already are. That doesn't mean it has to be "this old dinosaur," and he said many museums are not. But a museum's job involves keeping things, especially when it has a collection, and more broadly it involves "having a slower pace of things," which he said can be where many interesting things happen.
The interviewer closed by expressing the hope that institutions like theirs could do something good for the difficult situation the book describes. Lundkvist agreed, and the conversation ended there before the break and the readings.
Bombing goods.
Palma, for art and money, the economies of art. It is a format in which we reflect on these relationships between artistic creation and the lives of artists, who also need to earn money.
And what better occasion than to have a book, Planned Obsolescence: A Retrospective, which is now being published for the first time in Spanish with Nagi bookz, Atlas Projectos and the Fundación Juan March, accompanying the exhibition Aesthetics 1960–2020, which can be visited at the foundation's headquarters in Madrid between October 2026 and January 2027.
Today we propose something a little unusual. I hope you like it. What we will do first is a brief exchange with our guest in English, with Spanish subtitles at the top of the screen. In approximately half an hour, we will take a break to offer you a glass of wine. Afterwards, we will return to this room, with or without a glass of wine, for excerpts in translation from Planned Obsolescence, so that those of us here can think about the contents of this book and share ideas and impressions from the reading.
Our guest this evening is Henning Lundkvist. He lives in Copenhagen and describes himself as a writer, librarian, and occasionally an artist. Besides writing about the work and exhibitions of other artists, he spends time teaching and exhibits his own work every so often.
As well as the book Planned Obsolescence: A Retrospective, which came out in English in 2018, he has published Jolene in 2018, Columns, 2023, NCC, Draft and Organstuck, all from 2024. He's the founder of the publishing company Inaktiv, which is also the title of his solo retrospective held at the Vermilion Sands Gallery in Copenhagen in 2023. Please join me in welcoming Henning Lundkvist.
Thank you. Thank you.
So, Henning, how are you?
I'm good. That's basically everything I've ever done, what you said there.
It was, yeah.
That's all.
Excellent. I'm sure not, but anyway, this book we have in our hands. I won't ask you too much detail about the book itself because we will talk about it afterwards with the readings from it. But more in general, I wanted to ask you a few questions about how you came to write it, how you wrote the book, I mean. And, for example, how was your routine, your writing routine? What other things were you doing at the same time?
I'm one of those people who do a bit too many different things at the same time. So writing this book was one among many things, let's say. It was written in relation to an exhibition that took place in Porto in 2018, and the first edition was published by Gonçalo, who's here, who was also designing it together with me. So it came about in relation to an exhibition.
That's how the idea of making it into a book came. There was an occasion for the publication. The idea for the book was maybe not directly related to that exhibition. It came from the very first sentence of the book, which starts with, "It is true that I had accumulated a lot of cultural capital, but I had never managed to convert it into cash."
And then I thought, this is both very stupid but also very true, and then let's see if I can write a book where I just follow this line. The line becomes like this. And the writing process also was a bit like that. It was sitting a weekend and producing 30 pages, and then it took a few weeks before I had any time to sit and write at all again, and then came a few sentences, and then I was busy with stuff.
I had at the time recently moved to Copenhagen, working in a bar most of the time. So I was kind of busy with a lot of stuff that has to do with life.
And how has your life changed since? What keeps you busy most of your time these days?
Since I wrote the book, which is really somehow about money and art, I am luckily in a slightly better position than I was at the time when I wrote it in terms of money. I'm currently actually doing a PhD at the library of the Design Museum Denmark about the historical collection, working on that, which is very interesting and which means that I'm actually writing a fair amount now as well. But I'm writing for an audience of maybe 10 people who would find it interesting. It's a very niche collection.
Good PhD, then.
Yeah, if it's 10, then it's a good PhD. Otherwise, it's maybe five. But it's this thing where you have been doing sort of niche things with a rather small audience for all my grown-up life anyway, or since I was 13 and played in a punk band the first time. And now I'm actually writing for the full audience because everyone who would be interested in the subject will probably read it, and it's five or 10 people. So in that sense it's a full 100% hit factor, right?
May I ask what the subject is?
It's a historical image collection from the late 19th century that was collected as inspiration for designers and craftsmen. So it's 50,000 images or so, prints and photographs of door handles or ceilings or frescoes and different things. So it's a Pinterest or Google image search from the late 19th century.
Excellent.
Yeah.
And so, in your book you write as an artist, but there's also an autobiographical, but also a wider interest in economics. How did that come to be? Are you particularly interested in economics by itself, or just as an artist who has to make a living?
I think as an artist you really feel economy. If you want to say it in a diplomatic way, this is very much felt in your body for every artist. I mean, if you really make it, then you feel it as well, right? And otherwise, you would feel it in different ways. So in that sense, I wouldn't say that it's maybe an interest in that, but I've always been interested in what is behind things.
The structure behind it, the connections between different things, so to say. Same also in art, like the institution or the conditions for showing art, or even the walk to the Kunsthalle, I generally found more interesting than what I found in the Kunsthalle. And I guess maybe here it's also the economy behind the art becomes something interesting to me because it defines so much. I mean, to a certain extent, it defines so much of what can happen. On the other hand, so much happens despite economy, right? So it's this double relation. Yeah.
Because sometimes, as you mentioned in your book, the attitude to money in the art world can be a bit dismissive, as if money is a dirty thing we prefer not to talk about, and artists are pure beings that exist on their own. But that's clearly not reality, right?
And I mean, having written this book, it was published in 2018. It's very much about how it is to be an artist and maybe not suffering, but having a hard time making ends meet, being able to pay your rent, et cetera. And it's also written in a way that it can talk to a lot of people who feel the same way. Let's say in that sense it has a target audience.
That also means that for some years people wanted to talk with me, of course, about this book a lot, and then I got rather fed up because I wrote this because I needed to get this stuff out of my head rather than having everyone saying, "Oh, I feel the same as well." And then we have to talk about money.
But it is true that there is something in, I guess, the art world, or whatever you would call it, where it's not something you talk about that much. And if you do, then it's only about the very top, like the most expensive works ever sold, et cetera. It's not about how does this whole thing actually work or doesn't work.
Right.
And I try not to give you spoilers, but also part of the conclusion you come to is that it basically doesn't work, right? There are important flaws that are not unique to your experience but actually very widespread in the art scene.
Yeah.
So it's in a way a rather pessimistic book, or realistic.
I don't think it's that pessimistic. I mean, partly it has humor in it. So you should all read it to see how fun it can be when something doesn't work economically as well. But to me, I think a lot of it also had to do with using something as material, and then you produce something out of it. Then you can use also the rather—not tragic, that sounds very big—but the very boring economic situation and the big pressure you're under as a young, which I was at the time, younger artist, to use that to actually produce a new work, which is this book.
So in that sense, part of it is maybe pessimistic, but other parts of it are also like, okay, but then you can produce something new out of that. This gives the material for something else as well. Although, of course, it doesn't paint a very happy picture of the state of the world.
No, but there's definitely humor and no self-pity that I can see. So it's clearly a good point of view. I was curious about what you mentioned a moment ago, that you were part of a punk band.
Yeah.
In what capacity?
Well, one capacity was we had a garage where we could rehearse. So landlord, I guess, then. I played the bass, and then I tried to play most other things as well, but I was not very good at much else than the bass.
But yeah, I come from a very musical home, a musical family. So there were always instruments, and then I started to play. I don't know if I thought it was punk at the time, but it was punk, I guess, and then coming more into much more experimental things quite early. So I was lost already at an early age.
Yeah.
I find it interesting because the book itself, it's difficult to classify. You say at some point that it is a novel, and I guess you could see it as a novel, but it's also a bit like slam poetry or hip-hop. There's definitely something, the repetitions and the pace, the rhythm. There are no full stops, so it reads a bit like poetry or the lyrics of some sort of pop music, I guess. And also it is more an essay than a novel, right?
Yeah, I think to me it wasn't so important which one it was. But it's not like it has a protagonist, and this protagonist is very similar to me at the time of writing it. But when you say it's a novel, it gives you certain freedoms, right? Then you can, for example, skip the full stops. It gives you some freedoms.
I don't agree with everything in the book. That is also a huge difference, I guess, from if it were an essay or a novel. I mean, or not necessarily a novel, but some kind of fiction or autofiction, if you want. Because in this case, for me, it was a lot of: you start with this sentence, and then you see what happens.
And then you follow, if you try to explain art through economy, through the eyes of a young struggling artist. And then you keep that, and then you push this into becoming a full book length. I mean, it's a short book, but it's still a book, to see what happens if you do that. That also means that you follow the logic of something rather than that you follow your own ideas of how the world works.
And I mean, in the end, if you do this, if you follow art through the economy, then art is always going to lose. Because economy wins. So that's, I guess, the sad part of it. If you see art only from the economic point of view, then art will be on the losing side.
That's kind of just how it works. So in that sense, the perspective is also flawed, right? I don't claim that this is the best way of explaining how art works or how the art world works. It's more like this is one way, and what if you follow it? What comes out of it when you do that?
So I've had, both after I've done readings from the book, also from artist peers who have read it, some people who can relate and think it's really interesting or like it, whereas others say, "This is so depressing, I had to stop reading it. Because otherwise, I will stop making art." And I didn't write this in order to make people not make art.
You haven't stopped making art.
I don't make that much, but I don't want other people to stop.
Right. Although inflation is one of your main concerns, right? There's too much.
There is too much, but there's also, I mean, there's too much of everything. This is not a specific problem of contemporary art. There's too much of—
Contemporary life.
Yeah, exactly. And this is not something new either. In relation to my PhD thesis, I'm now reading a book about information management systems from the 1500s where the people were also complaining that there were too many books, and there wasn't that much, really. So this is nothing new, that you complain that there's too much of things is of course nothing new. This is a continuous complaint. But it doesn't make it less true, I guess.
One of my reactions after reading the book was I felt a bit like if I had watched one of these rather long, complex films, a very ambitious film, and leaving the theater, the soundtrack remains in my head and I would sing a little bit. I think what you have captured is what you sing in your head after consuming this artwork, or the world of contemporary art more specifically. It's the sort of flavor that remains after digesting a huge, complex and difficult thing.
You mean that the book has that flavor, or that you had that flavor after reading it?
I thought the book has that flavor.
Okay, yeah. That's a nice way of... That sounds very nice because then somehow it's a smell. Exactly.
Over the years, I collected quotes that other people say about my works or my practice, also things that I don't agree with. There's a friend of mine, now I forgot exactly which word he used, but he thought that a lot of the stuff I do is like a spray. That it comes into the room, and then it's there for a while, and then it disappears.
And then I guess this one is the spray coming out of me processing all of this stuff coming in and then out through the computer, and then out comes a book. So I guess maybe that's a little bit what you mean, perhaps.
And another way of putting it is you have a really fun moment in the book when a group of tourists gives a tour. They're giving a tour, and they describe the book to themselves. So they say, "Planned Obsolescence: A Retrospective, a book that broke the taboo of speaking about the storing of unsold works of art. The book is by no means a masterpiece, but it is an important document of its time, and its popularity paved the way for thousands of new storage facilities for art."
Let's see if it happens. I mean, we're on the third edition in English and the first in Spanish, so it keeps booming, right? So it can still happen.
And if I may ask you, you've kept thinking about possible solutions to the very complex problem that you describe. And one aspect in particular, I remember when you mentioned that there's an element of youth and idealism in breaking the art world, or breaking what was built before.
And you say in a rather cynical aside that back then you didn't realize that when young people break things, it's not the young who gets to rebuild, but the powerful.
Did I write that?
How can we rebuild stuff that is broken or malfunctioning?
I guess this is, of course, a really big question. And only because I wrote that doesn't mean I can answer it at all. I take no responsibility for what's in that book.
But I guess it is something also, again, of having, maybe from music when I was young and also from illegal downloading, that I had many friends who were very involved with that. I, of course, have never done anything of the sort.
There is something naive. In that case, I think that is what you're referring to. That is kind of a rather naive idea of the internet, in this case early 2000s, I guess. Feeling free, open, like information wants to be free, etc., etc. And then, in the end, what you get is Spotify and Google. And things have not gotten better since 2018 when I wrote that, because Spotify is a very small and cute little actor, of course, if you compare it to the big AI stuff that is happening now.
In this case, I guess, the breaking was also breaking those structures and trying to break free, and then the power—this has happened before, right?
Yeah. When you break an institution, which you often want when you're young, and speaking at least from my perspective, because you want something else. If that means that the institution that actually worked becomes completely smashed and everything becomes privatized, then that was maybe not the best thing that could happen.
And finally, one last question from me before we go get a glass of wine and continue talking in a different format. How do you think about museums? First of all, would you call yourself a museum goer?
I work in a museum, so I go there every day. I have a PhD at the Design Museum. I do go to museums. I'm not a museum buff who goes, like some people would always go to that. I'm not in that sense, no.
And would you say the way museums and art galleries present art is different in any way? Or do you think we could do something interesting in a different way from what the art market does?
Of course, and I think that is always, that is hopefully in different ways and should be in different ways. To me anyway, the art and culture that I find interesting always in the beginning appears in a basement or somewhere, in a rather small artist-run, musician-run venue if it's music, artist-run. That's often where you see the first things, right?
Some of these things then end up in the commercial side as well, in galleries and commercial galleries. Some does not. And then museums generally come a bit later, but that's also part of the museum's role, right? A museum is not necessarily supposed to be too fast. There are a lot of other things that are fast.
And the museum, of course, it doesn't mean that it needs to be this old dinosaur, but there are a lot of museums that are not and that still keeps this. There's a way of, about maybe not only keeping. Of course, if it's collection then it's about keeping, but also this of having a slower pace of things. That can also be where a lot of interesting things can happen as well, of course.
Absolutely.
And hopefully presenting it to the public and so on.
Yeah.
I hope we can do something good for this difficult situation that you describe.
Yeah.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thanks.
Article published · Updated
